
Forever Cheddar Mackinac Mix
Cheddar. White Cheddar. Mackinac Island Caramel. Three flavors. One legendary relationship.
This is what happens when opposites attract and actually make it work.
Forever Cheddar brings together smooth white cheddar, bold golden cheddar, and that warm, toasted sweetness only Mackinac Island caramel can deliver. It’s crunchy, it’s light, and it’s just sweet enough to make your inner child happy without making your grown-up self roll your eyes.
Each bite is a little buttery, a little salty, a little sweet... basically, everything you were craving at 3 p.m. when your to-do list gave you attitude. And let’s be real, you’re not just snacking, you’re choosing something that actually lives up to its name. No greasy fingers. No fake flavors. No "why did I eat that?" regret.
It’s the feel-good flavor trio you didn’t know you needed... reliable, tasty, and yes, still flirty. So go ahead. Treat yourself like someone who knows a good thing when they taste it.
Because you’re not here for mediocre snacks. You’re here for popcorn that shows up fresh, crunchy, and delicious… every time.
ALLERGENS
Nut-free and gluten-free
Contains coconut oil, soy lecithin, artificial color and dairy
Mix and Match Flavors Deal for sizes Small - Medium - Large
Buy 3 Bags get $4 off
Buy 4 Bags get $5 off
Buy 5 Bags get $6 off
Buy 8 Bags get $9 off
Buy 10 Bags get $11 off
We're confident you'll love our products. If you're not satisfied for any reason, let us know and we'll make it right or offer you a refund.
Most (not all) flavors are available in a popcorn tin
We ship fresh and frequently asked questions, learn more