Skip to content
Order today for your party and special events
Order today for your party and special events

American Classic Cheddar and Caramel Tin Mix

Original price $19.95 - Original price $37.95
Original price
$19.95 - $37.95
Current price $19.95


We make popcorn fresh daily because that's how it is supposed to be done. Real hand-crafted popcorn made by people, not in a giant factory.

Our popcorn is fresh and sealed in a tin for you to enjoy. Share with your family or eat it all by yourself.

Our classic popcorn mix is inspired by the nostalgic popcorn of Mackinac Island in Northern Michigan, where time moves just a little bit slower. We use real butter, molasses, and brown sugar in our Mackinac Island caramel. We add extra cheese to our Cheddar Cheese popcorn, but not so much cheese that it gets soggy and stale.



  • Air Popped
  • Real Cheddar Cheese
  • Crunchy and buttery
  • Molasses brown sugar caramel
  • No cardboard aftertaste like store-bought tins


  • Small Tin: Volume 1 Gallon
  • Medium Tin: Volume 2 Gallons
  • Large Tin: Volume 3.5 Gallons


    • Nut-free
    • Gluten-free
    • Popped with coconut oil
    • Contains soy lecithin
    • Contains dairy


    Orders ship Monday through Friday within 48 business hours with tracking numbers. Occasionally delays happen due to popcorn production, weather, shipper delays out of our control (UPS or USPS), and events out of our control. If you need an order by a specific date, give yourself some extra time. Do not wait until the last moment.


    1. Place your order online
    2. Cravings will fulfill your order
    3. You will receive fulfillment notice by email or text
    4. Call (517) 252-4782 when you arrive
    5. We will bring your order to your car

    You can use this service to simply order ahead. When you receive a notification that our order is fulfilled, you can come to the store to pick-up your order.

    Please note: Occasionally tins may have slight dents or blemishes that occur during shipping the process