Skip to content

Forever Cheddar Cheddar Mixes

We call it Forever Cheddar Cheddar when you mix cheddar cheese and white cheddar cheese together.

These items only ship
Be sure to select items that have this special shipping icon. We can not mix and match shipped items with items that are for curbside or local pick-up. All of these flavors are packaged after you place your order in special heat-sealed packaging.
 
Be sure to use our free shipping deals or deals sent to your inbox. Some of the best deals are e-mailed to you if you're on our list. So sign up today!
  • Cheddar Cheese and White Cheddar Cheese Mix
    $6.95

    Forever Cheddar Cheddar Mix | Ships

    Cheesy Cheddar Cheese mixed with our delicious White Cheddar Cheese popcorn. It's a cheese lover's dream. FEATURES Real cheddar cheese Real white...

    View full details
    $6.95
  • Caramel Cheddar and White Cheddar Mix
    $6.95

    Forever Cheddar Original Mix | Ships

    We've added our buttery smooth Original Caramel to our Cheesy Cheddar Cheese and delicious White Cheddar Cheese popcorn mix. FEATURES Real cheddar...

    View full details
    $6.95
  • $6.95

    Forever Cheddar Mackinac Mix | Ships

    We've added our sweet and salty molasses-based Mackinac Island Caramel to our Cheesy Cheddar Cheese and delicious White Cheddar Cheese popcorn mix....

    View full details
    $6.95
  • forever cheddar hawaiian popcorn | cravings gourmet popcorn
    $6.95

    Forever Cheddar Hawaiian Mix | Ships

    We've added our sweet and salty Hawaiian Salted Caramel to our Cheesy Cheddar Cheese and delicious White Cheddar Cheese popcorn mix. FEATURES Real...

    View full details
    $6.95